Is CBT for ED Effective?

Today we're talking about cognitive behavioral therapy or CBT: what it is, what the research says about its effectiveness and my personal take based on 20+ years of helping guys resolve ED.

What is CBT for Erectile Dysfunction?

OK, First, what is it?  CBT is talk therapy, but not the kind where you just talk about your feelings while the therapist nods [strokes his Freudian goatee and says, "How do you feel about that?"  CBT is structured and goal-driven.   With ED,  the therapist would work with you to identify and challenge your irrational beliefs related to performance, intimacy, and self-worth.  With the idea that if you can improve your thinking, you'll be feeling better.  Once you're feeling better, your erections will come naturally.  

CBT for ED Research Results

A 10-session CBT program that focused on enhancing communication between partners, increasing sexual skills, and reducing sexual anxiety, found that ED decreased by 50% by the end of the program.  

Another study showed that CBT completely resolved ED for 41.7% of men and largely resolved it for a further 27.8%.

One study was done specifically for younger guys with ED (recent data says psychological ED is increasing in younger guys).  The conclusion was that it's "a promising treatment choice in younger men suffering from ED."

And it can even work online.  A six week study of guys doing web-based CBT resulted in most guys having "significantly greater improvements with regard to erectile performance."

And in comparing it to Viagra-type drugs,  two studies found CBT alone to be significantly superior to Viagra alone. 

OK, so pretty good, 40-60% improvements with just CBT.  But for the amount of time involved in doing the sessions and the exercises and the amount of time it might take to see results, I can see how you might be a little hesitant in choosing CBT to solve your mental ED.

Here's where things really get interesting.  Meta studies: where researchers analyze results from multiple studies to draw bigger conclusions.

One of these meta studies looked at 13 papers covering 597 guys. The conclusion?  The combination of psychological interventions (including CBT) and a Viagra-type drugs was more effective than either CBT or Viagra alone.  In seven studies, the COMBINATION of the therapy and the meds was "significantly superior" to both Viagra alone and to CBT alone.

A second meta study I found said pretty much the same thing.   Just note there was some couples and group therapy mixed into those first results.

So the conclusion I get from having read a bunch of the research is: that CBT for ED is effective, it works for a lot of guys.  CBT combined with viagra or similar meds works even better.

MY OPINION ABOUT CBT for ED?

I love science.  Research says it works for most guys.  Great.  I'm totally on board.  Beyond that....take this with as big a grain of salt as you like: again I'm not a doctor or a psychologist.  And the guys who succeeded with CBT don't call me, so my perspective is a bit skewed.  

What I hear from the guys who've struck out with CBT has been something to the effect of "I really understand my problem and I can tell myself to think differently, but I don't FEEL any different."  So for some guys I think it connects at the intellectual level, but it's not getting them all the way to the point where they can really feel the change.  They're not getting that deeper shift.  BIAS ALERT!!! That's where I find hypnotherapy can be useful -  sometimes as a way of helping guys to really "get" the CBT ideas at a deeper level, sometimes as a way of working on the deeper blocks that kept the CBT from being effective. Just my two cents.

So if you're trying to decide which approach is going to be most effective for solving your mental ED, CBT is a solid choice. Add in some Viagra or similar drug and it's even better.